Stephanie Hall

Impact Innovation • Creative Technology

Back to Mission/Shift
Child Safety
AI Ethics

The ENFORCE Act: Why AI Crimes Need Real Consequences

By Stephanie Hall2025-12-05 17:53 6 min read
Share:
The ENFORCE Act: Why AI Crimes Need Real Consequences

What is the ENFORCE Act (H.R. 4831)?

  • The bill was introduced August 1, 2025 in the House of Representatives.
  • Full name: "Enhancing Necessary Federal Offenses Regarding Child Exploitation Act" (i.e. “ENFORCE Act”).
  • Its aim: to update and strengthen existing federal laws related to child sexual abuse materials (CSAM), child pornography, and obscene visual representations of child sexual abuse — especially in the context of modern distribution methods and technologies.
  • A win for victims: The ENFORCE Act would remove the statute of limitations under certain sections. That means these crimes could be prosecuted regardless of how much time has passed since the offense (this is a big deal).
  • Overall: gives law enforcement stronger tools, more clarity, and broader reach to address evolving forms of child sexual abuse material, especially digital and AI-enabled content.
  • **What to watch: **The ENFORCE Act strengthens laws but doesn’t solve prevention alone. Tech-enabled abuse still often evolves faster than legislation. Enforcement helps, but it doesn’t replace smart design, proactive detection, and supportive care for survivors.

Our team at Zero Abuse Project has spent the last year watching prosecutors struggle with cases they know are wrong but can't quite fit into our existing legal framework. A child is exploited. Images are created and distributed. But because AI generated the content, suddenly everything gets murky.

This isn't theoretical for us at Zero Abuse Project. Through our Trauma-Informed Prosecutor Project (TiPP), our staff talks with prosecutors across the country who are hitting walls they never expected. They're seeing real harm to real children, but the legal tools feel outdated for the technology causing that harm.

That's why I was thrilled to see Thorn highlighting the ENFORCE Act this week. Finally, someone is saying what we've been thinking: our laws need to catch up to reality.

When Technology Outpaces Justice

We've built incredible training tools like the NOVA Tool and our ICAC Resource Portal to help law enforcement & prosecutors understand and combat child exploitation. We've trained over 5,000 professionals nationwide on trauma-informed approaches.

But all that training hits a ceiling when prosecutors can't secure consistent consequences for AI-generated crimes against children.

I've sat in rooms where seasoned prosecutors look exhausted.

They know a child has been harmed.

They know images were created using that child's likeness.

But proving the case under current federal statutes? That's where things get complicated. The ENFORCE Act addresses this head-on by modernizing federal statutes and strengthening sentencing requirements. It ensures that offenders who commit crimes involving AI-generated CSAM face serious, consistent consequences, regardless of how their cases are charged.

This matters because justice shouldn't depend on which prosecutor you get or how creatively they can interpret outdated laws.

What This Means for the Frontlines

Through our TiPP program (funded by OJJDP), we provide free training and technical assistance to child abuse prosecutors and multidisciplinary team members. We've expanded this work nationwide, offering everything from live trainings to multi-day experiential courses.

We also provide free case consultation to child protection professionals.

In every single training, prosecutors ask about AI cases. How do you charge them? What sentences can you seek? How do you explain to a jury why AI-generated images deserve the same consequences as traditional CSAM?

Right now, the answers vary wildly depending on jurisdiction, interpretation, and prosecutorial creativity.

That inconsistency isn't just frustrating for legal professionals. It creates gaps that offenders exploit.

The ENFORCE Act would eliminate much of this uncertainty. When prosecutors have clear, consistent legal frameworks, they can focus on what they do best: seeking justice for victims.

Beyond Legal Framework: The Human Cost

As a mother, this hits differently too.

My kids are growing up in a world where their images could be weaponized in ways I never had to worry about when I was a kid. At Lilac Creative, we help nonprofits embrace AI responsibly, always asking: how do we harness this technology's power while protecting the vulnerable?

But individual responsibility only goes so far. We need systemic change.

The children affected by AI-generated CSAM experience real trauma.

I'm going to say that again in all caps so you don't miss the main point of this article:

THE CHILDREN AFFECTED BY AI-GENERATED CSAM EXPERIENCE REAL TRAUMA.

Their families face real consequences. The communities working to protect them need real legal tools that match the scope of the problem.

I've seen the data through our ICAC Training Program. I've talked with survivors through our work on the SurvivorSpace website. The harm is identical, whether images are AI-generated or not. Our legal consequences should be identical too.

What Thorn Got Right

Thorn's focus in their blog on prosecutorial clarity resonates deeply with our work at Zero Abuse Project. One of our main objectives is to "advocate policies that create and sustain a culture of prevention, disclosure, accountability, and healing."

The ENFORCE Act embodies that objective perfectly. It strengthens accountability mechanisms while providing the clarity prosecutors desperately need.

When legal professionals can do their jobs effectively, we create stronger systems of prevention and healing.

This isn't about being tough on crime for its own sake. It's about matching our response to the reality of harm being caused.

Moving Forward Together

At Zero Abuse we're constantly thinking about how technology can serve justice rather than undermine it. The ENFORCE Act represents the same philosophy: use innovation to strengthen protection rather than weaken it.

We publish microlearning videos and self-paced courses, we present at national conferences, we consult on individual cases.** But all of that work becomes more effective when it operates within a legal framework that acknowledges current realities.**

The prosecutors we train want to do right by victims. The law enforcement professionals using our tools want to prevent exploitation effectively. The ENFORCE Act gives them better tools to do both.

This is also about building trust in our systems. When families see consistent consequences for crimes against children, regardless of the technology used to commit those crimes, they're more likely to report, more likely to cooperate with investigations, more likely to believe that justice is possible.

A Call We All Should Answer

I'm not a legislator. I'm a program manager who builds training tools and a mother who worries about the world we're creating. But I know what I see in this field every day.

Our legal frameworks need to evolve as quickly as the technology threatening children. The ENFORCE Act represents exactly the kind of forward-thinking policy we need.

Whether you're a parent, a nonprofit leader, a technology professional, or someone who simply cares about child protection, this matters to your work too. Clear, consistent legal consequences create safer communities for everyone.

The question isn't whether AI will continue advancing. It definitely will. The question is whether our protection systems will advance alongside it.

Stephanie Hall

Written by

Stephanie Hall

Technology & Innovation Lead working at the intersection of AI, nonprofit innovation, and child protection. Founder of Mission/Shift.

Follow on LinkedIn

Get new Mission/Shift articles by email

No spam. Just practical analysis, strong opinions, and the occasional reminder that “innovation” is not an excuse to avoid accountability.

You can unsubscribe anytime. Your information will not be sold or shared.

Book Stephanie to Speak

Ethical AI, nonprofit innovation, child safety, and trauma-informed technology.

Learn More